Wikipedia:WikiProject Trade/Maritime jade route
 | This project page or section is in a state of significant expansion or restructuring. You are welcome to assist in its construction by editing it as well. If this project page has not been edited in several days, please remove this template. If you are the editor who added this template and you are actively editing, please be sure to replace this template with {{in use}} during the active editing session. Click on the link for template parameters to use.
This page was last edited by Mathglot (talk | contribs) 2 months ago. (Update timer) |
This page is a central repository dedicated to providing background, data, edit info, references, links, and generally anything that may be of interest to editors in the improvement of articles related to the use of the terms "Maritime jade route" and "Philippine jade culture".
Intent and scope
[edit]The intent here is to provide valid and demonstrably repeatable data, statistics, evidence, etc. about the usage of the term Maritime jade route (and secondarily, Phillippine jade culture) at Wikipedia and in sources. If it is not obvious where the data comes from, a link, explanatory note, or methodology description is included. Analysis, interpretation, or discussion is out of scope on this page and should be carried out elsewhere, linking to this page as needed.
List of articles involved
[edit]As of 21 February, 2025, there were 20 mainspace inlinks to "Maritime Jade Road" and nine inlinks to "Philippine jade culture" in articles.
with the term Maritime Jade Road
[edit]with the term Philippine jade culture
[edit]Articles that link to Philippine jade culture
|
|---|
deleted articles
[edit]- on <some date> user <some userid> created page Philippine jade culture (t.b.a.)
- 2021-08-18 06:46 Gibedapse moved page Philippine jade culture to Maritime Jade Route
- 2021-08-18 06:47 Gibedapse moved page Maritime Jade Route to Maritime Jade Road
- 2021-08-20 13:18 Anthony Appleyard deleted page Philippine jade culture (G6: Deleted to make way for move) log
- 2025-01-09 12:27 Randykitty deleted page Maritime Jade Road log (G8 (redirect): Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philippine jade culture closed as delete (XFDcloser)
- 2025-01-09 12:27 Randykitty deleted page Maritime Jade Route log (G8 (redirect): Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philippine jade culture closed as delete (XFDcloser))
Relevant edits to involved articles
[edit]This section is a summary of some of the more important edits related to use of the terms Maritime Jade Road and Philippine jade culture.
Articles
[edit]There are 43 mentions of "maritime jade road" in all namespaces, 33 mentions in articles.
The general format is SSV (semicolon-separated variable)[a], containing:
- article; userid; timestamp; diff; remark1; remark2;
where the remarks are optional.
Edits introducing Maritime Jade Road to articles
|
|---|
|
Users
[edit]Eight users were involved in introducing the term Maritime jade route for the first time in 33 articles; below is a summary of the edit profile of these editors and a link to their xtools edit-count stats page:
| user (linked to xtools edit count) |
article count |
first WP edit | last WP edit | live | del | total | del pct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 103.152.9.5 | 5 | 2021-08-19 00:22 | 2021-08-19 00:55 | 11 | 1 | 12 | 8% |
| Charles Jayson Zaldivar | 1 | 2023-05-26 02:01 | 2025-02-12 08:03 | 39 | 10 | 49 | 20% |
| Gibedapse | 9 | 2021-07-30 07:49 | 2021-12-02 23:34 | 139 | 31 | 170 | 18% |
| Laska666 | 2 | 2020-07-06 18:40 | 2022-09-04 17:31 | 4099 | 41 | 4140 | 1% |
| Mlgc1998 | 1 | 2018-12-23 17:53 | 2025-02-16 17:10 | 4014 | 104 | 4118 | 2.5% |
| Obsidian Soul | 4 | 2009-12-05 14:16 | 2024-12-20 02:58 | 54596 | 685 | 55281 | 1.2% |
| Rene Bascos Sarabia Jr. | 7 | 2008-11-13 11:00 | 2025-02-24 03:15 | 5750 | 112 | 5862 | 1.9% |
| Spitmyrno | 4 | 2021-08-18 21:36 | 2021-08-19 02:37 | 47 | 18 | 65 | 28% |
Term frequency in sources
[edit]Books
[edit]Using ngrams to compare the frequency of the expressions Maritime Silk Road and Maritime Jade Road ini indexed books reveals that there are plenty of references to Maritime Silk Road, especially in the last ten years, but there aren't enough of Maritime Jade Road to meet the minimum threshold required for ngrams to plot it: ngrams link. (Note: searching case-insensitive is no different.)
Top colocation prefix terms for * jade culture are of and the (i.e, of jade culture and the jade culture). The following ngrams link is designed to surface the top ten trigrams ending in jade culture, but only these two appear, the remainder being below the ngrams threshold: * jade culture.
Journals
[edit]This section is about coverage of the term in academic journal articles. Google Scholar was used and returned nine results, but a couple were books, and one was a course syllabus for an Indian university. The search link is: [1], which returned the following results (full citations hidden in the wikicode):
An exact search at Google scholar for maritime jade road" returns these nine results (eight unique):
- A Forgotten Maritime Highway: Maritime Cultural Heritage of the Emperor Seamounts with Implications for High Seas Conservation, Journal of Maritime Archaeology, 2024
- Jade: A Gemologist's Guide, The Journal of Gemmology, 2022
- The Great Silk Road and its impact on Cultural exchange and Economic development in Ancient Civilizations, at CyberLeninka repository, 2024
- Coastal Geology as a Science Through Time, Coastal Geology, 2022
- Exploring Urban Ethnobotany: A Case Study of Medicinal Plants Traded in Gede Hardjonagoro Market, Surakarta, Indonesia, Tropical Journal of Natural Product Research 2024
- Ruta comercial Editar artículo [Trade route edit the article], Wikibrief (in Spanish; mirror site)
- Coastal geology, JA Morales - 2022; same source as #4, this one a Google books result.
- The history of hydrological studies on the Mekong floodplains – from colonial experiments to computational models, Hydrological Sciences Journal 2024
- Ancient Societies, Lessons 1–12, Himachal Pradesh University (n.d.) course syllabus. (Note: same as #2 in § Web section below.)
Web
[edit]This section attempts to portray the presence of the term on the web at present, and in the past by using Google web search with restricted time windows (as well as archived versions at Internet Archive, not yet included). Part of the goal is to determine when the web pages first appeared.
Maritime Jade Road
How many occurrences of the term Maritime Jade Road are there at different time periods and when did it first appear on the web?
Methodology: Google web search, using custom time window, excluding social media[c], and requesting 100 results. (Note: web search is case insensitive.)
Show number results of quoted search term "Maritime Jade Road" as of:
- Undated: 41
In the past:
- 1/1/2021: 3
- 5/1/2021: 3
- 8/18/2021: 3
- 1/1/2022: 3
- 5/1/2022: 3
- 9/1/2022: 3
- 1/1/2023: 3
- 5/1/2023: 3
- 9/1/2023: 4
- 1/1/2024: 4
- 5/1/2024: 8
- 9/1/2024: 9
- 1/1/2025: 13
- 2/1/2025: 13
- 3/1/2025: 14
- no date: 41 (includes undated pages)
The three early web pages that had the term before approximately 5/1/2023 are:
- Sejarah Pendirian,[1] a school demo website and blog platform owned by an individual in Indonesia. The sentence on the page that includes the search term has four footnotes numbered 17–20, each citing a footnote at the Wikipedia History of Indonesia article with the same footnote number. (There is now finally a saved version in Internet Archive; previous save attempts in the last few days failed several times.)
- Ancient Societies, Lessons 1–12, Himachal Pradesh University (n.d.) course syllabus. (Note: same as #9 in § Journals section above.) Three occurrences on p. 70: "Initiated by the animist indigenous peoples of Taiwan and the Philippines, the Maritime Jade Road was an extensive trading network connecting multiple areas in Southeast and East Asia." This sentence is present in Nephrite, Trade and Trade route, and variations of it are present in many more.
- English–Uzbek translator website, showing 30 KWIC-like snippets of English containing the word jade along with the Uzbek translation for them. One of them contains the expression maritime jade road: "Cagayan was a major site for the Maritime Jade Road, one of the most extensive sea-based trade networks of a single geological material in the prehistoric world, operating for 3,000 years from 2000 BCE to 1000 CE." (As of 24 Feb. 2025, this sentence is still present in Cagayan.
Philippine jade culture
How many results for the exact phrase "Philippine jade culture" in journals, books, and the web:
- Scholar: zero results in Scholar.
- Books: three results in Books.[d]
- Web: two results on the web (social media excluded).
See also
[edit]- Talk:Trade route#Should section Maritime Jade Road be blanked?
- Wikipedia:Village pump (miscellaneous)/Archive 78#Is this a Wikipedia error now appearing as an RS?
- deletion log for Maritime Jade Road
- deletion log for Philippine jade culture
- Afd: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philippine jade culture
- User talk:Toadspike/Archive 2#Philippine jade culture cleanup
Notes and citations
[edit]- Notes
- ^ SSV (semicolon-separated variable) is easy to convert to a wikitable if desired when the data stabilizes. In the meantime, SSV is easier for editors to maintain than a table, and unlike the more common CSV, does not use a character common in article titles.
- ^ Methodology: articles in the edit list are as discovered by WikiBlame via binary search with 'Force searching for wikitext' checked and a default start date. This date may vary from 21 through 23 February 2025, depending on when WikiBlame was employed. Because WikiBlame searches backwards from start date, an item appearing in the (initial version of) the list does not mean it was the first introduction of the term to an article; the term could have been introduced earlier, removed, and then re-introduced with the edit shown in the list.
- ^ The web search query excludes the following terms: wikipedia, wiki, twitter, reddit, instagram, linkedin, facebook, pinterest, quora, and amazon.
- ^ One hundred results were requested for the exact phrase "Philippine jade culture" Google's page rank algo returns 127 results on two SRPs, of which only the first three results contain the bolded search phrase.
- Citations
Works cited on this page
[edit]- Ariyanto, Dodi. "Sejarah Pendirian". SIMEdu.
Austronesian people form the majority of the modern population. They may have arrived in Indonesia around 2000 BCE and are thought to have originated in Taiwan.[16] During this period, parts of Indonesia participated in the Maritime Jade Road, which existed for 3,000 years between 2000 BC to 1000 AD.[17][18][19][20]
- The four citations quoted are the following, but the footnote numbers depend on revision and cannot be interpreted without knowing the revision referred to: