George Zurcher
George Zurcher (1852 - September 11, 1931) was an Alsatian-American Catholic Priest and anti-alcohol advocate.[note 1] Ordained in 1877, he served as a priest, predominantly at parishes in Western New York, for the rest of his life except for 1900–1906. While the chaplain of the poorhouse in Buffalo, Zurcher became convinced that the consumption of alcohol was an evil that should be personally avoided or, after 1895, banned.
Zurcher's strong beliefs came into conflict with the Catholic Church. He was reprimanded by Bishop Stephen V. Ryan in 1895 for sending a letter to the Buffalo Times that, in part, incorrectly attacked Jesuits in the Diocese of Buffalo for selling beer at a Catholic parochial school. Zurcher's third book, Monks and their Decline, was placed on the Index of Forbidden Books in 1898. On All Saints Day 1899, he gave a homily critical of the practice of collecting money for souls in purgatory. This lead to a six-year suspension from ministry.
In 1906, Zurcher's suspension was lifted and he returned to being a parish priest in 1907. He edited the quarterly publication Catholics and Prohibition 1909-1919, and helped found the Catholic Prohibition League of America out of frustration with the Catholic Total Abstinence Union of America in 1914. He died on September 11, 1931 and was buried in Eden Center, New York.
Early life
[edit]George Zurcher was born in Alsace in 1852.[1] He entered the seminary in Aachen, but did not complete his studies, instead immigrating to the United States in 1873.[1][2] Zurcher settled in Western New York, attending The College and Seminary of Our Lady of Angels, now Niagara University, to finish his degree in theology.[3] Zurcher was ordained on June 11, 1877, by Stephen V. Ryan, Bishop of Buffalo, at the seminary chapel, and was assigned to a parish in Boston, New York.[4] Subsequently, he served a parish priest in Limestone, New York and Cohocton, New York.[5]
Anti-alcohol advocacy
[edit]Temperance advocacy
[edit]Zurcher advocacy for temperance came from serving for 15 years as the chaplain of the poorhouse in Buffalo while assigned to a nearby St. Joseph's parish.[2][5] Interacting with the destitute and attending court "convinced him that alcohol was a curse and the root cause of all the social problems of the era."[2] In 1890, Zurcher self-published his first temperance book, Handcuffs For Alcoholism, describing the effects of alcoholism on the body and on society.[6] At the 1893 Catholic Total Abstinence Union of America convention, Zurcher gave a speech denouncing the practice of German-American catholic parishes circumventing the Third Plenary Council of Baltimore's prohibition of the church selling alcohol at church functions.[7]
Prohibition advocacy and suspension from ministry
[edit]In 1895, Zurcher transitioned from advocacy for temperance to advocacy for the total prohibition on alcohol due to the lack of enforcement of the Third Plenary Council of Baltimore.[8] In December he was censured by Stephen V. Ryan, second Bishop of Buffalo, for sending a letter to the Buffalo Times that attacked Jesuits in the Diocese of Buffalo claiming that they "owe more obedience to the Superior-General in Europe then to Bishop Ryan" and that beer was sold at a Jesuit school.[9]
His second book, Foreign Ideas in the Catholic Church in America, was released the next year. Zurcher argues in the book that Germans have had a negative influence on the Catholic Church in the United States.[10] In particular, he focuses on Saint Vincent Archabbey which, at the time, brewed Saint Vincent Beer.[11] Zurcher also argues that Catholics should be allowed to join the protestant Sons of Temperance because "the future of the church in many cities is in doubt" if Catholic and Protestants do not work together to end the consumption of alcohol.[8] Colman James Barry, a historian of the Catholic Church, criticizes Foreign Ideas.. as an "intemperate pamphlet" that focuses on the "Germans and their supposed efforts to divide the Church in the United States".[12]
Zurcher released his third book, Monks and their Decline, in 1898.[13] In it, he criticizes Saint Vincent Archabbey for brewing beer, chided it for not joining the temperance movement, claiming the monks were contributing to the drunkenness of lay Catholics, and mocked the post-nominal letters of Benedictines, OSB, claiming that they should stand for "the Order of Sacred Brewers".[14] The book was placed on the Index of Forbidden Books by the Sacred Congregation of the Index on September 5.[15] On December 31, Zurcher accepted the decision of the Sacred Congregation of the Index, withdrew the book from circulation, and promised to refund the purchase price.[16]
On January 4, 1899, Zurcher withdrew from anti-alcohol advocacy due to restrictions placed upon him by James Edward Quigley, third Bishop of Buffalo.[17] In November, Zurcher preached a homily attacking the church for collecting money on All Saints Day for souls in purgatory. Instead of retracting the homily as commanded by the Vicar-General of the dioceses, Zurcher nailed a copy of it to the pulpit.[18] Zurcher was suspended from ministry by Quigley in January 1900.[19] While suspended, he returned to anti-alcohol advocacy and unsuccessfully ran for New York State Senate on the Prohibition Party ticket.[20][21] In 1905, Zurcher released his fourth book, The Apple of Discord: Or, Temporal Power in the Catholic Church, arguing that the Catholic Church should cease the practice of censorship within the church and limit itself to a spiritual role in the world.[22]
Reinstatement and later advocacy
[edit]Zurcher was reinstated as a priest by Charles H. Colton, fourth Bishop of Buffalo, in January 1906.[23] For his first year after reinstatement, Zurcher was the chaplain of the Sisters of Mercy convent in Buffalo. For the rest of his life, he served as parish priest in Niagara Falls, New York, East Aurora, New York, and then North Evans, New York.[5]
In 1914, due to a lack of radicalism in the Catholic Total Abstinence Union of America, Zurcher left the organization and helped found the Catholic Prohibition League of America.[24] He edited the quarterly periodical Catholics and Prohibition between 1909 and 1919.[8] When the Eighteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution was ratified in 1919, Zurcher ended the publication because "the liquor problem had finally been settled once and for all".[25][26] He supported the National United Committee for Law Enforcement during the prohibition era which contended that a lack of enforcement was the problem, not prohibition itself.[25]
Death and legacy
[edit]George Zurcher died on September 11, 1931 after a long illness.[1] He was buried at Eden Cemetery in Eden Center, New York, on September 14, 1931, after a Requiem Mass celebrated by Herman Gerlach.[27]
A cenotaph was erected in Zurcher's memory in 1935 by protestant temperance groups in North Evans, New York, the location of his final parish.[28] Historian John F. Quinn considered Zurcher to be "probably the most militant Catholic prohibitionist priest of the time".[24]
Bibliography
[edit]- Books
- Handcuffs For Alcoholism (1890)
- Foreign Ideas in the Catholic Church in America (1896)
- Monks and their Decline (1898)
- The Apple of Discord: Or, Temporal Power in the Catholic Church (1905)
- Periodicals
- Catholics and Prohibition (quarterly 1909-1919)
Electoral history
[edit]| Party | Candidate | Votes | % | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Republican | George A. Davis | 17,143 | ||
| Democratic | George Staub | 13,530 | ||
| Socialist Labor | Theodore A. Venneman | [note 2] | ||
| Prohibition | George Zurcher | [note 3] | ||
References
[edit]Notes
[edit]- ^ Alsace was part of the Second French Republic when Zurcher was born in 1852, and was under the control of the German Empire when he left for America in 1873. At the time of his death in 1931, the region was back under French control. Sources refer to him as both French and German.
- ^ Not reported
- ^ Not reported
Citations
[edit]- ^ a b c "Death Ends Career of Noted Liquor Foe". Buffalo Evening News. September 12, 1931. p. 1. Retrieved 10 July 2025.
- ^ a b c Brady 1976, p. 426
- ^ "Priest, Friend of Dry Cause, Passes Away". Rochester Democrat and Chronicle. September 12, 1931. p. 10. Retrieved July 10, 2025.
- ^ "Ordination". Catholic Union. June 21, 1877. p. 8. Retrieved July 10, 2025.
- ^ a b c "Modest Priest of North Evans Serves God and Man Undismayed by Lack of Worldly Possessions". Buffalo Courier. December 16, 1923. Retrieved July 11, 2025.
- ^ "Handcuffs For Alcoholism". The Catholic World. February 1891. p. 771-772. Retrieved July 11, 2025.
- ^ Weisenburger 1962, p. 150-152
- ^ a b c Brady 1976, p. 428
- ^ "Ryan's Rebuke". Buffalo News. December 13, 1895. Retrieved July 11, 2025.
- ^ "Father Zurcher's Pamphlet". Buffalo Evening News. November 20, 1896. Retrieved July 12, 2025.
- ^ "Foreign Ideas: Father Zurcher Has Written Another Book". Buffalo Courier. November 20, 1896. p. 5. Retrieved July 11, 2025.
- ^ Barry 1952, p. 170
- ^ "Father Zurcher and His Book". Buffalo Evening News. November 16, 1898. Retrieved July 11, 2025.
- ^ Oetgen 2000, p. 231
- ^ "Forbidden Book". Buffalo Express. September 6, 1898. Retrieved July 11, 2025.
- ^ "Renounces His Book". Buffalo Evening News. No. January 6, 1899. p. 7. Retrieved July 10, 2025.
- ^ "Obeyed Orders". Buffalo Commercial. January 9, 1988. Retrieved July 11, 2025.
- ^ "Priest May be Removed". Buffalo Evening News. November 13, 1899. Retrieved July 11, 2025.
- ^ "Father Zurcher Out of His Church". Buffalo News. January 28, 1900. Retrieved July 11, 2025.
- ^ "Zurcher Spent a Two Cent Stamp". Buffalo Courier. November 19, 1900. Retrieved July 11, 2025.
- ^ "Tea Table Gossip". Franklin Evening News. September 2, 1901. Retrieved July 11, 2025.
- ^ Brady 1976, p. 433
- ^ "Father Zurcher Is Reinstated". Buffalo Enquirer. January 13, 1906. Retrieved July 11, 2025.
- ^ a b Quinn 1996, p. 638
- ^ a b Brady 1976, p. 432
- ^ Quinn 1996, p. 640
- ^ "Father Zurcher Is Laid to Rest in Eden Cemetery". Catholic Union and Times. September 17, 1931. p. 1. Retrieved July 10, 2025.
- ^ Brady 1976, p. 424
- ^ Wende, Otto H. (October 31, 1900). "List of Nominations of Candidates for Offices to be Filled at the General Election". Buffalo Evening News. pp. 6–7.
- ^ "49th Senatorial District". The Enterprise. November 7, 1900. Retrieved July 12, 2025.
Bibliography
[edit]- Barry, Colman J. (1952). The Catholic Church and German Americans. Milwaukee, WI: Bruce Publishing Company.
- Brady, James E. (1976). "Father George Zurcher: Prohibitionist Priest". The Catholic Historical Review. 62 (3): 424–433. JSTOR 25019924.
- Oetgen, Jerome (2000). Mission to America: A History of Saint Vincent Archabbey, the First Benedictine Monastery in the United States. Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press. ISBN 978-0813209579.
- Quinn, John F. (1996). "Father Mathew's Disciples: American Catholic Support for Temperance, 1840-1920". Church History. 65 (4): 624–640. doi:10.2307/3170390. JSTOR 3170390.
- Weisenburger, Francis P. (1962). Triumph of Faith: Contributions of the Church to American Life, 1865-1900. Richmond, VA: William Byrd Press.
