Follow this (organisation)
![]() | This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these messages)
|
Follow this is an independent Dutch non-profit organization and shareholder advocacy group, founded in 2015. The organization unites environmentally conscious investors - both institutional and private - by filing climate-related shareholder resolutions at annual general meetings of major oil and gas companies. Its aim is to push these companies to align their emission reductions with the targets of the Paris Agreement.
History
[edit]Follow this was founded in 2015 by Mark van Baal.[1] Follow this began as a small-scale initiative, born out of frustration over the role of oil companies in the climate crisis and the lack of influence that politics and society had over the corporate sector.[2] Van Baal realized that only shareholders had the formal power to force companies to change course, and he bought a single share in Shell to address fellow shareholders at the company’s 2015 annual general meeting.[3]
The core argument of Follow this is as follows: oil and gas companies significantly contribute to global warming through their emissions.[4] Destructive climate change will endanger the global economy. This poses a major risk to investment portfolios of institutional and retail shareholders across sectors.[5] At the same time, Big Oil has the know-how and resources to accelerate the energy transition. Shareholders therefore have an interest in ensuring that their company invests in renewable energy, rather than in new fossil fuel exploration. This helps safeguard shareholder value in the long term.[6][7]
In its early days, Van Baal, supported by a few volunteers, personally approached hundreds of private investors to join his mission. This created a collective of private “green shareholders” who could influence fossil fuel companies from within.[8] In 2016, the organization filed its first climate resolution at Royal Dutch Shell, which was still headquartered in the Netherlands at the time.[9]
This first climate resolution received 2.8% of the votes, after, among others, pension fund Actiam and asset manager MN backed the proposal.[10] In addition to the support of private investors, Follow this started to focus on convincing institutional shareholders to use their voting rights to urge Shell toward sustainable investment choices. In 2017, the votes in favor at Shell doubled to 6.3%.[11]
In the years that followed, Follow this grew into a serious player in the international financial world.[12] Each year, Follow this uses its rights as a minority shareholder to table resolutions that put climate issues on Big Oil’s agenda.[13] Breakthroughs came when international institutional investors began backing the resolutions[14] and oil and gas companies, under sustained shareholder pressure, started tightening their climate ambitions.[15] Follow this regularly features in the news when international media report on financial developments in the energy sector.
Organization
[edit]Follow this was founded as an association (vereniging) in the Netherlands, and boasts a membership base of several thousand[16] supporters—known as “green shareholders.” Since 2021, Follow this has been recognized by the Dutch Tax and Customs Administration as an official charitable organisation (ANBI).[17] The organisation is governed by a board of voluntary members, led by founder Mark van Baal, and supported by a small core team and a network of volunteers.[18]
Funding for Follow this comes mainly from philanthropic contributions, supplemented by membership fees and donations from supporters.[19] This funding model keeps Follow this independent from government subsidies or corporate sponsorship, helping preserve its grassroots character.
Shareholder votes for climate resolutions
[edit]Follow this filed its first shareholder resolution in 2016 at the annual general meeting of Royal Dutch Shell, which received approximately 2.8% support. Since then, it has submitted climate-related resolutions annually at oil majors, including Shell, BP, TotalEnergies, ExxonMobil, and Chevron. Voting outcomes incrementally increased in the first seven years, having stabilised around the 20% mark since. Some highlights include:
- 2016–2020: Incremental support at Shell, rising from 2.8% in 2016 to 14% in 2020
- 2021: ~80% support at Phillips 66, ~60% at ConocoPhillips, ~40% at Equinor, ~30% at Shell, ~20% at BP
- 2022: ~30% support at Chevron and ExxonMobil
- 2023: ~30% support at TotalEnergies
- 2024: ~20% at Shell
- 2025: No resolution filed, but ~24% support at BP against the chairman's re-election over climate strategy U-turn[20]
These outcomes are based on voting records reported by outlets such as Reuters,[21] The Guardian,[22] Euronews,[23] and Capital Monitor.[24]
Impact
[edit]Oil majors
[edit]Some Follow this resolutions have reached majority support, which in several cases forced the companies in question to take action. For example, its pressure reportedly influenced Shell to adopt Paris‑aligned emissions goals in 2018–19.[25] In 2021, majority support for a resolution at Phillips 66 led the company to announce an ambition to reduce Scope 3 emissions.[26]
At the beginning of Follow This's campaign, no major oil company accepted responsibility for Scope 3 emissions, those resulting from the use of their products. Through persistent shareholder pressure, four of the five supermajors, Shell, BP, TotalEnergies, and Chevron, now acknowledge that Scope 3 emissions fall within their responsibility. ExxonMobil remains the only holdout.[27]
Investors
[edit]Follow this works closely with institutional investors such as pension funds, insurers, and asset managers. With climate change increasingly viewed as a risk to both the global economy and the environment,[28] large shareholders use their own voting power to support Follow this resolutions and to mitigate exposure to potential stranded assets.[29]
Follow this also collaborates with institutional investors to co-file resolutions. A notable example was in 2023 at TotalEnergies, where the resolution was co-filed with international investors including Amundi, a leading French asset manager. In 2024, a similar coalition, representing approximately €4 trillion in assets and including NEST, Candriam, Scottish Widows, and Rathbones, co-filed a resolution at Shell.[30]
Anti-ESG backlash
[edit]Follow this encountered a major legal conflict in early 2024, when ExxonMobil filed a lawsuit in Texas federal court against Follow this and Arjuna Capital, aiming to block a shareholder resolution on greenhouse gas emissions. Amid a backlash on ESG proposals, Exxon pursued this litigation after the groups had withdrawn their proposal, arguing the matter could recur and seeking to restrict future filings through court orders.[31]
The move sparked widespread investor outrage. Leading institutional shareholders, including CalPERS and Norges Bank Investment Management, denounced Exxon for undermining shareholder rights. CalPERS announced plans to vote against Exxon's entire board in protest, calling the lawsuit "reckless" and "designed to punish two small groups that dared to speak truth to power".[32] Norges Bank publicly opposed the re-election of Exxon director Joseph Hooley, citing concern over the company's "unusual and aggressive tactics".[33] Dozens of asset owners collectively controlling trillions in assets issued statements defending shareholder democracy and urging reliance on SEC processes as the proper mechanism for resolving proxy disputes.[34]
In June 2024 the court dismissed the case against Follow this on jurisdictional grounds, and the case against Arjuna Capital was dropped after the firm committed not to refile the proposal. Follow this welcomed the ruling, warning the lawsuit could have set a dangerous precedent for future climate-focused shareholder activism.[35]
In early 2025, Reuters reported[36] that Follow this would, for the first time since 2016, not file any climate resolutions. The New York Times[37] attributed the decision to legal and political pressure in the United States, including state-level actions against ESG policies at American investors. Despite not filing a resolution, Follow this did successfully rally BP shareholders to vote against re-election of their chairman after a u-turn in the oil major's climate strategy[38].
References
[edit]- ^ "Climate activist shareholders to target US oil giant Chevron". The Guardian. 20 May 2021.
- ^ "Mark van Baal, luis in de pels van de oliemajors: 'Veel beleggers zitten vast in hun comfortzone'". De Tijd. 19 May 2023.
- ^ "Shell AGM 2015 - Mark van Baal speech". YouTube. 30 September 2021. Retrieved 8 August 2025.
- ^ "Synthesis Report of the IPCC Sixth Assessment Report". IPCC. 20 March 2023.
- ^ "Climate change poses big risks to financial stability, global watchdogs say". Reuters. 4 October 2023.
- ^ "Climate resolutions shaking up Big Oil". Financial Times. 14 October 2022.
- ^ "Groene aandeelhouder Mark van Baal: klimaatschade oliebedrijven negeren kost ons pensioengeld". De Telegraaf. 26 May 2023.
- ^ "Our Story". Follow this. Retrieved 8 August 2025.
- ^ "Follow this-oprichter Mark van Baal: 'Exxon wil critici permanent monddood maken'". NRC. 24 May 2024.
- ^ "Resolutions and results". Follow this. Retrieved 8 August 2025.
- ^ "Shell AGM 2017". Follow this. Retrieved 8 August 2025.
- ^ "Milieugroep Follow this pakt Shell aan met 4000 miljard steun van vermogensbeheerders". De Telegraaf. 25 May 2023.
- ^ "Climate resolutions shaking up Big Oil". Financial Times. 14 October 2022.
- ^ "Climat : une coalition de 27 investisseurs met la pression sur Shell". Les Échos. 14 May 2021.
- ^ "How Shell is trying to survive the climate crisis". TIME. 10 January 2020.
- ^ "Shell Ordered by Dutch Court to Cut Carbon Emissions". The Wall Street Journal. 26 May 2021.
- ^ "ANBI status controleren". Belastingdienst. Retrieved 8 August 2025.
- ^ "Our Story". Follow this. Retrieved 8 August 2025.
- ^ "FAQ". Follow this. Retrieved 8 August 2025.
- ^ "BP braces for investor rebellion at first AGM since climate strategy U-turn". The Guardian. 17 April 2025.
- ^ Climate activist shareholder group Follow this pauses big oil campaign, Reuters, 9 April 2025
- ^ BP suffers investor rebellion at first AGM since climate strategy U-turn, The Guardian, 17 April 2025
- ^ One big backlash, Euronews, 10 April 2025
- ^ How investors voted on climate change at big oil AGMs, Capital Monitor, retrieved 6 August 2025
- ^ How Shell is trying to survive the climate crisis, TIME, retrieved 6 August 2025
- ^ Investors ramp up pressure on big oil firms to set 2030 climate targets, Reuters, 19 December 2022
- ^ 'Not sufficient': ExxonMobil slammed over Scope 3 hole in net-zero pledge, Recharge News, retrieved 6 August 2025
- ^ US investors back away from climate, social reforms, Reuters, 11 July 2025
- ^ ESG Watch: Climate activist investors were sidelined this earnings season. They'll be back, Reuters, 29 June 2022
- ^ Shell faces shareholder rebellion over climate activist resolution, The Guardian, 16 January 2024
- ^ Exxon case against activist shareholder can proceed, Reuters, 22 May 2024
- ^ CalPERS Targets Exxon Board in Protest of Shareholder Rights Suit, Barron's, 22 May 2024
- ^ Norway wealth fund to oppose Exxon director over shareholder lawsuit, Reuters, 24 May 2024
- ^ Asset Owners Join Forces Against ExxonMobil, NordSIP, 28 May 2024
- ^ ExxonMobil drops lawsuit against Arjuna Capital, Financial Times, retrieved 6 August 2025
- ^ "Climate activist shareholder group Follow this pauses big oil campaign". Reuters. 9 April 2025.
- ^ "Corporate gloom". The New York Times. 14 April 2025.
- ^ "BP braces for investor rebellion at first AGM since climate strategy U-turn". The Guardian. 17 April 2025.